Encounters with Diasporic Consciousness and Bare Life

Art by LEM, Intersect Antigua-Barbuda.

As I sat in one of my social work classes, a fellow classmate asked the question “what is the role of the clinician in revolutions?” It is a question I’ve been sitting with since it was initially posed. In part, because my own preconceived notions of the field of social work were what brought me to it in the first place. According to the International Federation of Social Workers (IFSW):

“Social work is a practice-based profession and an academic discipline that promotes social change and development, social cohesion, and the empowerment and liberation of people.” 

It was, and continues to be, a mission that I could get behind as it aligned with my own values. As a Caribbean feminist researcher, I believe in fighting for a better reality in which everyone’s human dignity is recognized, safety is prioritized, and joy is central. A key component of this was moving from theory to praxis in a way that did not inflict further harm. I entered the field of social work with a strong belief that it would equip me with the skills and knowledge to be a community practitioner and better researcher.

Despite this, throughout my journey as a social worker, I have repeatedly felt underprepared to work in communities in meaningful ways. There would be brief, fleeting moments in which things would click, but I struggled to follow through on them. And so, when faced with the question, “what is the role of the clinician in revolutions,” I paused. Potential answers pushed me to reflect more deeply on the conditions informing the field of social work and their implications for my own experience. 

I came to social work searching for tools and knowledge that could be used in the service of fighting for a better reality. What I found instead was a field that had yet to truly acknowledge and embody the frameworks that would allow it to uphold its missions and values. To shed more light on this, the following essay offers something of a critical analysis of the historical and contemporary conditions that are informing the clinician’s positionality in revolutionary movements.  

“...when faced with the question, “what is the role of the clinician in revolutions,” I paused. Potential answers pushed me to reflect more deeply on the conditions informing the field of social work and their implications for my own experience. ”

Domination and “The Body”

To understand the clinician’s positionality, we must understand the historical landscape of the field, its colonial roots and what happened to “the body.” Through colonialism, power, domination, and racial hierarchy became systematized at a global level. Looking specifically at the Black body during slavery offers us an entry point to examine the impact of colonial systems. The trans-Atlantic slave trade was a system of domination—in addition to altering our material world—that profoundly ruptured the psychological dimensions of what it means to be human. Scholars such as Orlando Patterson (1982), Sylvia Wynter (2016), and Hortense Spillers (1987) have all argued from one vantage point to another that the Black body was completely stripped of familial connections, identity, and basic human rights through violence. The body was remade into a “slave”—a docile subject that a slave master could enact his will upon for pleasure and profit. This great rupture, sustained for centuries, in turn created this Hegelian dynamic of hyper-dependency in which the slave master could not exist without the enslaved (Patterson 1982). 

This dynamic echoes into the present in a manner akin to groundhog day syndrome. As the naming of the oppressed continues to evolve, the ability to directly name the oppressors becomes increasingly difficult as power becomes embedded throughout legal, social, and economic institutions. Thus, with each evolution, we move from a named master to an archaism—hiding in disguise at every stage—while sustaining the original ruling episteme of captivity and domination (Spillers 1987). The slave master and the enslaved are remade throughout time to adjust to the socio-political and economic conditions of society.  

For example, as the trans-Atlantic slave trade came to an end, the ruling European elites laid the foundation for a capitalistic, laissez-faire economic system to replace it (Holt 1991). Under this new system, the formerly enslaved were transformed into post-colonial subjects who made up the newly required labour force. This transformation was facilitated through a crusade of social and moral reforms in which institutions like penitentiaries and mental hospitals were introduced by the ruling European elites (Patterson 1982).  

This crusade allowed them to maintain their control over bodies while facilitating the evolution of racial domination and the capitalistic agenda. It also exemplified institutionalized control as the backdrop for the emergence of related fields of psychology and the helping profession (Walborn 2022). These fields of study and professions acquired the power to control and contain the aforementioned bodies under the guise of “do no harm” and “we are helping you” (Fanon 1963). Emerging in the 1800s alongside the development of racial science, social work would become another “helping” profession that would uphold this dynamic through its adaptation and standardization of Eurocentric beliefs, values, and practices (Walborn 2022).

A Fragile Commitment, A Longer History

Noting this history, the field of social work has since turned inward to reckon with its past and reconsider what role it will play in society. During the civil rights movement, social workers began to take up the mantle of social justice and reject the so-called “apolitical” and “neutral” positionality (Bent-Goodley 2014). This move gradually changed the landscape of the field. By July of 2014, a new global definition of the social work profession was approved by the IFSW General meeting and the IASW General Assembly (International Association of Schools of Social Work). This change rippled throughout the field as institutions began adapting human rights framing and using it to train a new generation of social workers. 

Black women across the African diaspora have specifically fought to expand the field’s human rights framing through the cultivation of frameworks such as Womanism, Caribbean Feminism, and Decolonial Healing Justice. They are inherently grounded in liberatory and human-centered approaches informed by Afro-diasporic consciousness (Taylor 2023). Afro-diasporic consciousness refers to the cultivation of communal and cultural knowledge, and a “group consciousness” of displaced people of African descent—against the backdrop of colonial violence—for political action (Smith 2016).[1]

This knowledge is alive. Life is breathed into as it is passed down through generations with the goal of preserving cultural practices and passing down strategies of survival and resistance. They are liberatory frameworks that address social markers such as race, gender, class, and sexuality that intersect, compound, and shape people’s experiences (Bryant-Davis and Comas-Díaz 2016). In a clinical setting, they provide us with a socio-political and cultural lens in which we can guide individuals to understand themselves better and develop strategies for coping and resistance. These frameworks do not stop at the individual level. They expand to the community and society because they are rooted in the recognition that in order to truly reckon with the wholeness and dignity of a person we need to cultivate a healing environment that can allow one to flourish (Taylor 2023).

Despite the offerings of new liberatory and human-centered frameworks, the social work profession struggles with meaningful change. This struggle is rooted in the profession’s longer history of determining which knowledge systems and modalities are valued. Clinical modalities such as CBT (Cognitive Behavioral Therapy), DBT (Dialectical Behavior Therapy), and ACT (Acceptance and Commitment Therapy) rose to the top of the clinical field as the gold standard. These modalities and their subsequent branches emphasize the individual as it primarily focuses on pathologizing people's experiences and assisting them with developing effective strategies to manage current and future stressors that occur at both a structural and interpersonal level.  

There are social work practitioners who have begun to utilize newer frameworks alongside these modalities to enhance their practice and clients’ experiences. Predominantly, however, practitioners are taught and continue to employ these modalities without a fuller analysis of intersectional, structural failures that impact how people show up, their mental and physical health, and their ability to cope. The profession's privileging of particular therapeutic knowledge at the expense of critical and liberatory frameworks reinforces the notion that being unable to cope and participate fully in society is an individual failure rather than a response to one’s material conditions.  

Crossroads

Presently, the far-right authoritarian regime that has been ushered in by the current United States’ presidential administration is rippling out to the rest of the world in the form of Western imperialism. In the Caribbean, we are witnessing political leaders jeopardize our safety, human rights, and autonomy as they align with this regime (Ramdass 2026). The United States, as a result, has been allowed to engage in a genocidal campaign across the region unchecked. From launching lethal strikes on vessels in the Caribbean killing more than 234 people over the course of 68 strikes to the imposed oil blockade in Cuba resulting in a mounting humanitarian crisis (Robinson 2026; Whitney 2026). During this period, Cuba’s death rate reportedly increased from 9.5 deaths per 1,000 persons in 2014 to 14.2 deaths in 2025 (Whitney 2026).

“The profession’s privileging of particular therapeutic knowledge at the expense of critical and liberatory frameworks reinforces the notion that being unable to cope and participate fully in society is an individual failure rather than a response to one’s material conditions.  ”

Amidst this growing regime, the social work profession has largely remained silent and begun to capitulate. In January 2025, there was a wave of U.S anti-Diversity Equity and Inclusion federal executive orders that were quickly adopted across the country. Where institutions once made a commitment to racial justice, we now see capitulation and over-compliance in which they are scrubbing frameworks and language in favour of colorblind policies that reinforce, rather than mitigate, racial asymmetries. Social work as a profession has begun to follow suit in an attempt to comply with the administration’s orders (ISP 2026). While there can be an argument that it is better to hunker down in this moment and do the work in the grey, it is important to note that when institutions eagerly engage in over-compliance it simultaneously exposes the fragility of the commitment to social justice and liberatory praxis. The removal of language and frameworks must be taken seriously as they are the tools that have been cultivated by those who came before us and those who continue to labour for a better world. Their absence also gives way to colonial ideals and practices taking firm root once more. 

The International Federation of Social Workers, broadly, and the Caribbean region chapter, specifically, have remained silent as these events unfold, rather than taking a stand against these atrocities and affirming their commitment to social change and the liberation of people. The silence is deafening. It is also violent as it normalizes what is occurring. Furthermore, it reinforces the age-old dynamic in which the field of social work has historically been a tool to ensure that people can survive under violent, oppressive regimes. 

Given the historical roots and contemporary actions of social work, it is hard to believe that the profession actively wants to live up to its liberatory commitments. Yet, I believe there are glimmers of hope emerging, including efforts to transform the field into a vehicle for change. As social workers, we must not simply help people cope with these conditions but actively participate in the creation of new conditions in which people no longer have to survive them. To do this, we must:  

  1. Reckon with our history, positionality, and access to power. 

  2. Realign our commitments to social justice and fortify ourselves against fascist regimes.   

  3. Recognize, value, and legitimize therapeutic frameworks that have grown and developed out of Afro-diasporic consciousness.  

As scholars have noted, social work at its best “is a transformative process in which both social conditions, participants, including the social worker, are changed in the pursuit of a just world.”[2]

Endnotes

[1] Smith (2016) defines “diasporic consciousness” as “the (mental) tightrope that people of African descent…walk as they try to balance their superordinate racial identity (and the political interests associated with it) with their subgroup or ethnic identity and its closely associated political interests.” (p. 46)

[2] Freire as quoted in Marilynn Moch’s 2009 article, “A Critical Understanding of Social Work by Paolo Freire.”

Works Cited

Bent-Goodley, Tricia B. 2014. “EDITORIAL: Social Work and the Civil Rights Act of 1964.” Social Work, Vol. 59, No. 4, pp. 293–95. http://www.jstor.org/stable/24881359. 

Bryant-Davis, Thema, and Lillian Comas-Díaz, eds. 2016. Womanist and Mujerista Psychologies: Voices of Fire, Acts of Courage. Washington, DC: American Psychological Association.

Fanon, Frantz. 1963. The Wretched of the Earth. New York: Grove Press.

Holt, Thomas. 1991. The Problem of Freedom: Race, Labor, and Politics in Jamaica and Britain, 1832-1938. Johns Hopkins University Press.

ISP. 2026. “CSWE Is Abandoning the Values It Exists to Protect.” Influencing Social Policy. https://bit.ly/4C9kGMi.

Moch, Marilynn. 2009. “A Critical Understanding of Social Work by Paolo Freire.” Journal of Progressive Human Services, Vol. 20, No.1, pp. 92–97. https://doi.org/10.1080/10428230902878285.

NASW. 2021. “NASW Apologizes for Racist Practices in American Social Work.” NASW - National Association of Social Workers. June 17, 2021. https://www.socialworkers.org/News/News-Releases/ID/2331/NASW-apolog izes-for-racist-practices-in-American-social-work.

Nixon, Angelique. 2020. “The Elements of Decolonial Healing Justice.” TEDx Talks. YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7J_BD0Jjk5c. 

Patterson, Orlando. 1982. Slavery and Social Death: A Comparative Study. Harvard University Press.

Ramdass, Anna. 2026. “PM Stands by Trump.” Trinidad Express. November 5, 2026. https://trinidadexpress.com/news/local/pm-stands-by-trump/article_baf15cbe-189b-42fc-9ed7-a01918227572.amp.html.

Reisch, Michael. 2019. “Lessons from Social Work’s History for a Tumultuous Era.” Social Service Review, Vol. 93, No. 4, pp. 581–607. https://www.jstor.org/stable/26957072. 

Robinson, Pearce. “Extrajudicial at Sea: 234 Dead, and a Region That Will Not Say the Word.” Pearce Robinson, September 23, 2026. https://pearcerobinson.com/reporting/extrajudicial-at-sea-caribbean-strikes.

Smith, Candis Watts. 2016. “Diasporic Consciousness: Theorizing Black Pan-Ethnic Identity and Intraracial Politicals.” Black Mosaic: The Politics of Black Pan-Ethnic Diversity. New York: NYU Press, pp. 45-68.

Spillers, Hortense J. 1987. “Mama’s Baby, Papa’s Maybe: An American Grammar Book.” Diacritics, Vol. 17, No. 2, pp. 65–81. https://doi.org/10.2307/464747. 

Taylor, Foluke. 2023. Unruly Therapeutic: Black Feminist Writings and Practices in Living Room. New York: W. W. Norton & Company.  

Walborn, Ellie. 2022. “Dynamics of Color: Whitewashing in Social Work History.” Social Current. March 14, 2022. https://bit.ly/48ZXsLb

Weheliye, Alexander G. 2014. Habeas Viscus: Racializing Assemblages, Biopolitics, and Black Feminist Theories of the Human. Duke University Press.

Whitney, W. T., Jr. 2026. “U.S. Blockade of Cuba Converts to Siege as Deaths Increase.” People’s World,  https://www.peoplesworld.org/article/u-s-blockade-of-cuba-converts-to-siege-as-deaths-increase/.

Wynter, Sylvia. 2016. “On How We Mistook the Map for the Territory, and Reimprisoned Ourselves In Our Unbearable Wrongness Of Being, Of Desêtre: Black Studies Toward the Human Project (2005).” In I Am Because We Are: Readings in Africana Philosophy. Eds. Fred Lee Hord, Mzee Lasana Okpara, and Jonathan Scott Lee, Revised Edition. Amherst: University of Massachusetts Press, pp. 267–80. http://www.jstor.org/stable/j.ctt1hd18x6.31. 

Aniah Francis

Aniah Francis is an Afro-Trinidadian advocate for Black girls, femmes, and gender expansive youth across the African Diaspora, who currently serves as Research and Writing Fellow at the African American Policy Forum (AAPF).

Aniah recently obtained a Master of Arts in Social Sciences at the University of Chicago and is in the process of completing another Master's in social work, social policy, and social administration at the University of Chicago 2024-2026. Prior to this, Aniah attended the University of San Francisco where she studied Sociology with a concentration in Criminology, Law and Society and minored in African American Studies, Legal Studies, and Public Service and Community Engagement.

Her research interests focus on the experiences of Black girls across the diaspora as it relates to structural failing around their gender, race, and sexuality. She hopes to continue deepening her knowledge and developing her research and advocacy skills.

Next
Next

Jessie Mayers, Our Filmmaker-In-Residence